Lists all devices attached to your home network, identifying name and type when possible. Flags devices that may be vulnerable. Offers advice for vulnerabilities. Reports new devices connecting to network.
Advice is the same for most vulnerabilities, pushing the Bitdefender Box network security device. Can't sort or export the device list.
- Bottom Line
Bitdefender's free Smart Home Scanner lists every device that's connected to your network, flagging those that could be vulnerable to attack. But advice on how to fix things is limited.
Just how many computers, mobile devices, and Internet of Things (IoT) gadgets connect to your home network? You need to answer that question before you can consider what sort of protection you might need across the network. Bitdefender Smart Home Scanner aims to help you with that initial inventory, and it can even identify devices that are vulnerable to specific attacks. It's a nice first effort, and it's free, but it could be even more useful with a few changes.
You don't have to pay for this app, but during installation you do need to create a My Bitdefender account, or sign in to your existing account. Once the installation is complete, the utility launches and readies itself for its first scan. To start, it asks you to confirm that it's connected to your home network, and warns that using the product on public networks is not recommended. With that housekeeping out of the way, it goes directly to scanning.
Your home network router assigns a unique, local-only IP address to every connected device. Smart Home Scanner communicates directly with the network adapter to identify the possible local-only addresses that correspond to devices on your network. To do so, it simply sends a network packet to each address and notes which ones respond.
Once it has that all-important list of devices, it starts checking each of them for security vulnerabilities. On my test system, the full scan took about five minutes.
If you ever use a VPN, you may have noticed that connecting to the VPN can cut you off from devices on the local network. To use a local device like a networked printer, you may need to temporarily disconnect from the VPN. Because Smart Home Scanner connects directly to the network adapter, it can still scan your local devices even when you're using a VPN. However, my Bitdefender contact informs me that while such a scan will get the correct list of devices, the VPN might interfere with accurate analysis of each device's security status. For best results, turn off your VPN before running this scan.
Once the scan finishes, it's time to review the results. On my own network, Smart Home Scanner found between 23 and 26 devices, depending on which devices were turned on. For each device, the report lists the name that it found, along with the local IP address. For computers and similar devices, it pulled the actual device name, such as "NeilWindows10" or "Janets-iPad." Others got clear but generic names like "HTC One phone" or "viziocastdisplay." An icon indicates the device type, be it computer, TV, printer, or even garage-door opener. Most importantly, the list flags each device with a green label saying it found no risks, or an orange label warning of potential risks.
Clicking any item brings up a page with more detail, including the manufacturer, the device type, the IP address, and the device-specific MAC address. I did observe that in some cases it identified the device type, but didn't have an icon for it. That was the case for a couple network-attached storage devices and a Roku media player.
Then there were a few with a name like "unknown8C883B97EC3," with an unknown device type. At first, I thought there was no option to change the name if I managed to identify the device, perhaps based on the manufacturer name. However, my Bitdefender contact pointed out the subtle three-dot menu indicator at top right, which includes the option to edit the device name and type. When I did change a name, the scanner remembered that name on a subsequent scan.
Here's an interesting feature: When a new device connects to the network, Smart Home Scanner pops up a notification and offers to scan the device. However, you don't get to choose whether that device gets to connect, the way you do with Wi-Fi protection in Panda Antivirus Pro. Panda's scanner, which only works on Wi-Fi, alerts you to unsafe Wi-Fi connections, and offers advice on improving the security of your own Wi-Fi network.
Avast Free Antivirus includes a network scanner, but it doesn't go as deep as Smart Home Scanner. When I put Avast's network scanner to the test, everything came up safe except for one PC that intentionally connects through the router's DMZ port, thereby losing the protection of a local-only IP address. In addition, while it reported on computers, routers, printers, and other major devices, it didn't seem to catch the full range of IoT devices the way Smart Home Scanner did.
Dealing With Vulnerabilities
In Smart Home Scanner, the detail page for each device has a banner at the top. A green banner means the device doesn't seem to be vulnerable to attack, while an orange one indicates that the scan found possible security vulnerabilities. In the latter case, you can click again for details and recommendations. And here's where the product falls down, just a bit.
With your first click, you get a list of vulnerabilities found on the device. Clicking one of those gets you to the actual details and recommendations. I checked every single vulnerability found by the scan, and found that the recommendations never changed. The description of what attackers might do by exploiting this vulnerability was always the same. And the advice on how to fix it always said that the provider should fix the vulnerability with an update…or you could buy the Bitdefender Box to secure your whole network.
The detailed information was the same for every vulnerability I saw, but apparently that isn't always the case. My Bitdefender contact told me that there are some differences in reporting what could happen, and that in some cases, such as weak credentials detected, the advice on how to fix the problem gets more specific.
At a list price of $199, plus a $99-per-year subscription after the first year, the Bitdefender Box is a far cry from the free Smart Home Scanner. However, it does protect every device on the network, preventing connections to dangerous URLs and fending off potential attacks. It even functions as a VPN server, so your mobile devices remain protected even when away from home. While it can replace your home router, it's not great at that job. Our testing indicated that it works best in conjunction with a powerful home router.
Wouldn't It Be Nice If…
The repeated advice to buy Bitdefender Box, along with the colorful advertisement for that product at the top of the main scan window, might suggest that Smart Home Scanner is nothing more than an advertising ploy for the Box. However, I see it as a useful free tool, one that could be even better with a little fine-tuning.
The list of scanned devices comes up in no particular order, or perhaps in the order in which the devices responded to Smart Home Scanner's initial query. That makes finding one particular device quite difficult. I'd love the ability to simply sort the list by name; the option to sort by IP address might also be handy.
If you don't find a device in the list, it surely corresponds to one of those pesky unknowns. Wouldn't it be great if Smart Home Scanner allowed you to export its list of found devices? You could then disconnect the problem device, scan again, and see which item vanished from the list. As it is, the only way I've found to identify a problem device is to power it off, run a scan, then power it back on and take note when Smart Home Scanner reports a new device on the network.
Then there's the always-the-same advice I encountered. In truth, different types of vulnerabilities lead to different types of exploits, and there may well be ways to fix the problem without waiting for a security update, or purchasing a Bitdefender Box. I'd like to see advice that's specific to the vulnerability in question, where possible.
Worth a Try
Since it won't cost you anything, the Smart Home Scanner is worth a try. You may be surprised to learn how many devices are exchanging data on your home network, securely or otherwise.
If network security scanning inspires you to seek a whole network security solution, the Bitdefender Box is naturally one option, but it's not the only one. We're seeing many more entries in the realm of Internet of Things security, and we'll be testing them soon.
Other Bitdefender Security
Neil Rubenking served as vice president and president of the San Francisco PC User Group for three years when the IBM PC was brand new. He was present at the formation of the Association of Shareware Professionals, and served on its board of directors. In 1986, PC Magazine brought Neil on board to handle the torrent of Turbo Pascal tips submitted by readers. By 1990, he had become PC Magazine's technical editor, and a coast-to-coast telecommuter. His "User to User" column supplied readers with tips… More »
More Stories by Neil J.
- The Best Malware Removal and Protection Software of 2017
Malware comes in many forms, but one thing's for sure—you don't want it attacking your computer. We'… More »
- The Best VPN Apps for the iPhone
Your iPhone may be well protected against malware, but it can't protect your data as it travels the … More »
- TrackOFF Basic
Modern websites quiz your browser to generate a fingerprint that uniquely identifies you, so they ca… More »